Rating the Brand that Rates Us All: YELP!

Rating the Brand that Rates Us All: YELP! Rating the Brand that Rates Us All: YELP! Rating the Brand that Rates Us All: YELP! Rating the Brand that Rates Us All: YELP! Rating the Brand that Rates Us All: YELP!
by Annie Libertalis
With spring finally on the horizon and as terraces of cafes and restaurants become more enticing than ever, consumers have numerous options to sift through when it comes to outdoor dining options. In a city chock-full of restaurants to dine at, museums to visit, and activities to partake in, consumers will first be confronted with the need to decide where exactly they will spend their time and money.

Thanks to websites and apps such as YELP, consumers can make the city’s myriad options a bit more digestible, narrowing things down based on user-generated ratings and reviews. With the omnipresent use of mobile devices, consumers can easily peruse reviews on their next outing to guarantee a successful experience. Since people tend to trust other peoples’ endorsements before they trust those of businesses, YELP has been integral in serving as a portal for information on small businesses and service providers since 2004.

The power of consumer reviews is undeniable; positive or negative, what people say about a brand influences others and can greatly impact a brand’s success, and this is no less true for brand YELP. As such, while YELP provides reviews on various other businesses ranging from retailers to doctors to salons, we wondered what it would look like if consumers could rate YELP itself. The BAV framework allows for a brand agnostic evaluation of YELP, meaning it can be compared and contrasted to any other brand in the market, across different industry categories.

On the bright side, YELP is seen as a helpful, innovative resource. The greater American population rates YELP highly on those characteristics and sees the brand growing its popularity as shown by its increase in monthly visitors to as many as 120 million in 2013.

annie yelp 1

As aforementioned, positive and negative reviews greatly influence business success and, like it or not, YELP reviews matter for consumer esteem and loyalty. But the importance of YELP has created a secondary market of purchasing/selling reviews. While some genuine negative reviews can be trusted and motivational for the business to improve upon its shortcomings, others can be precipitated by competitors or purely hateful customers. To counter that, YELP has developed an automated system that filters out untrustworthy reviews. YELP also prohibits businesses from incentivizing consumers to leave glowing reviews. While these systems have been put in place to protect against abusing the framework, these measures are unpopular among some short-changed owners who do not get adequate credit for honest positive reviews that did not make the cut.

While YELP relies on critical mass of networks and crowd-sourcing to guarantee representative and truthful ratings, giving it a nice 4.5/5 Social score on the BAV attribute scale, its credibility is sometimes called into question by consumers since YELP’s business model relies on business owners’ advertisements. As a result, trusting YELP as an unbiased, independent source has become a challenge for consumers. While BAVC has identified that the importance of trust has increased over time (correlations of Trust to Brand Strength went from 0.29 in 2001 to 0.42 in 2013), Americans think that YELP is only more trustworthy than 55% of all brands, essentially rating it at around a little over a 2.5 rating on a YELP scale.

annie yelp 2

Although the YELP brand is still growing its Stature, the future potential of the brand has declined since 2010.

annie yelp 3

While the brand has consistently increased its Knowledge/Awareness and stabilized its Relevance, the brand has lost some of its momentum and Differentiation, the first telltale sign of a brand becoming a commodity. While YELP is still a strong Niche brand, it has lost ground on perceptions of being “Worth More” and “Authentic”. Consumers also question its quality, performance and genuine customers’ interest.

annie yelp 4

Overall, with higher Strength and lower Stature, YELP’s Brand Asset BAV score is 2 stars. Will YELP bounce back and get enough positive recommendations to increase its score in the future? The company’s expansion to other platforms (allowing users to complete transactions and orders directly from its app) may help revamp its differentiation and increase Relevance. Stay tuned!

annie yelp 5


All Content © 2017 BrandAsset Consulting

Subscribe to BAViewsletter, our monthly newsletter, and to weekly BAViews, our blog, to keep up to date with BAV’s latest insights.


Our monthly newsletter with the latest insights on specific subjects.

BAViews: Our Blog

A weekly article written by our specialized staff on relevant subjects.


By checking the box, you are indicating your consent to receiving further communication from us. For our opt-out process, please read our Privacy Policy.

Thank you
for subscribing!

Please check your inbox
to confirm your email address.

Contact Form

Fill out the form below letting us know what you’d like to talk about and we’ll get back to you.

Job Title

We do not share your information, please read our Privacy Policy.

Thank you!

Your message has been submitted successfully.